Creamy mustard chicken with winter veg, £1.06

by Susan Bell for A Girl Called Jack

by Susan Bell for A Girl Called Jack

This hearty, saucy dish is delicious in the winter, served with root vegetables and rice or mashed potatoes, or in the summer, with green vegetables and tossed over pasta. Any mustard will do for this – I keep English in the fridge, but wholegrain or any other sort will work fine. Use this recipe as a base, and adapt as you wish.

Serves 2-4 depending on appetite (eg serves 2 adults and 2 toddlers in my house, with rice on the side)

4 tablespoons oil (vegetable or sunflower will do), 8p
4 chicken thigh fillets, £3.60 for free range (personal choice, I know not everyone can afford it so there are cheaper options available, but I’m honest about what I use)
1 large onion (approx 150g), 9p
1 large carrot (approx 100g), 8p
1 teaspoon English mustard, 2p
500ml chicken or vegetable stock, 3p
a handful of fresh parsley, 8p
1 tsp mixed dried herbs, 6p.
200ml natural yoghurt, 20p or double cream if you prefer

Heat the oil in a medium-sized non-stick saucepan and put in the chicken. If using thighs, drumsticks or breasts with skin on, place them in skin side down. Cook for 5 minutes on each side on a medium heat to seal. If using bacon, chop it into 1cm chunks and toss into the pot with the chicken.

Peel and chop the onion and wash and slice the carrot, and add to the pan. If using tinned carrots, simply drain and tip in. Stir the mustard into the stock and pour into the pan to cover the vegetables and half-cover the chicken. Finely chop the parsley and thyme and add to the pot. Cover with a lid and cook for 20 to 30 minutes until the chicken is cooked through.

Remove the chicken and stir the cream into the sauce in the pan. Boil rapidly for a few minutes to thicken the sauce. If you’ve got yoghurt rather than cream then add it off the heat after reducing the sauce – adding it on the heat means it will split and curdle. Still perfectly edible, just doesn’t look so great. If you’re nervous about splitting the sauce (or a novice cook), pour the yoghurt into a bowl and add a few teaspoons of the hot sauce to the yoghurt. Stir well, and repeat, until the yoghurt-sauce-mixture is a warm temperature, then tip the lot over the chicken and stir through.

Tips: green beans make a great addition to this dish – in fact, chuck in any vegetables that are kicking around. As a rule of thumb, add root veg shortly after browning the chicken and add small veg like peas, shredded greens or green beans 5 minutes before serving. For a vegetarian version, just leave out the chicken and put in more veg as required.

Creamy Mustard Chicken With Winter Veg recipe from A Girl Called Jack by Jack Monroe, available from all good bookshops and supermarkets, but please try to buy it from Hive, who will deliver it to your local independent book store (or your house):

*Prices worked out at Sainsburys as it’s my nearest supermarket, but similar products are widely available at other supermarkets. Also subject to change as prices do, correct at time of blogging. Check for up to date information about what’s available where you live, and if you find really good bargains, please comment below as I’m sure my readers would love to hear them!
Vegetable oil £4/3l. Bag of Basics onions, 95p/1.5kg. Bag of Basics carrots, 85p/1.5kg. Basics English mustard, 35p/180g. Basics chicken or vegetable stock cubes, 25p/10. Fresh parsley, 80p/28g. Basics mixed dried herbs, 40p/13g. Basics natural yoghurt, 50p/500g.

Follow me on Twitter & Instagram @MsJackMonroe

Categories: Blog


  1. As I am wary of msg in most stock cubes, I prefer to keep a bucket in the freezer where I toss in chicken bones and veg scraps to be used to make stock in a crock pot. It’s healthier and other then the minimal energy used by slow cooker on par or better then stock.

  2. Making this with Quorn pieces and fat free natural yoghurt tonight. Hope it works out well! Smells lovely so far.

  3. Got all those bits kicking around in the freezer and veg drawer, so thank you. That’ll do nicely for tonight’s dinner.

  4. Lovely recipe,I do a similar dish using crème fraiche and I stir in a tablespoon of honey to sweeten it, it works really well with the mustard. I use any seasonal vegetables that are available and sweet potatoes and squash are a particular favourite in our house. Keep up the good work.

  5. This recipe was very popular with my entire family and will definitely become a regular on the family menu! Thank you Jack!

  6. Just to update – it was bloody delicious! I made it for three adults (me, the fella and one portion for my Stanley flask at work). I made quite a few mods:
    1 large onion, 1 large carrot, 1 large parsnip, 1 tin of artichoke hearts that have been in the back of my cupboard since Henry VIII was knocking about and a bowl full of spinach for the veg.
    180g of the RealEat chicken style pieces. I used 60ml of whey I froze after making paneer, 500ml vegetable stock. 4 tsp of English mustard (which at first I thought was excessive but maybe I have a high tolerance for mustard!) 2 tbsp of 0% fat creme fraiche (had no issues splitting), 2tsp dried thyme, 1 tsp dried parsley, reduced sodium salt and black pepper to taste.

    By my calculations on MyFitnessPal, served with 50g (uncooked weight) brown rice this is just under 500 calories but packs a nice punch protein wise – I am very impressed given its so moreish, comforting and creamy.
    I would never normally try something like this dish and I’m so glad I did!

  7. It needs AT LEAST half the amount of stock and yoghurt. There was no sauce even after trying to reduce, just watery stock slightly cloudy with yogurt. Stock just won’t thicken enough in these proportions. Ended up with more of a boiled chicken soup. It’s strange as Jack’s mushroom stroganoff recipe with a similar kind of method is perfection. That’s 100ml of stock just to compare, which makes me think there’s been an error here.

Leave a Reply